Via ClickZ News (Zachary Rodgers)
State laws that set up "Do Not E-mail" registries for children are actually putting those kids' contact info at risk, according to a letter penned by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
The letter's ostensible purpose is to address proposed child protection legislation in Illinois; but it also appears designed to warn other states that have set up -- or are considering setting up -- such lists of their inherent dangers.
"Because such a registry cannot be effectively monitored for abuse, it may have the unintended consequence of providing spammers with a mechanism for verifying the validity of e-mail addresses," the letter states. "This consequence may actually increase the amount of spam sent to registered children's addresses in general, including spam containing adult content."
Utah and Michigan have already passed legislation to create such lists. The well-meaning laws are meant to protect children from commercial messages that promote adult content and other products prohibited to them. However, the FTC asserts such registries have the reverse effect. It says they let unscrupulous marketers quickly identify and sell to kids, since they offer an available database of verified e-mail addresses. Meanwhile, it asserts they hurt legitimate marketers, who must spend money and time comparing their lists against them.
These databases are vulnerable, the FTC notes, because they typically work by scrubbing existing lists and returning those lists with the contact information of registered children either highlighted or removed. Unethical parties can thereby deduce which individuals on its pre-scrubbed list are children, and then e-mail them. Finding and prosecuting spammers is notoriously difficult.
For the full article, go to
FTC: State Registries Put Kids' Inboxes at Risk